| 4th Period Play-by-Play |
| | Start of 4th period [15:00]. |
| [15:00] | Faceoff Nick Benhoff vs Sam Limpert won by RMCML, [15:00] Ground ball pickup by RMCML Tim Rowe. |
| [14:45] | Shot by RMCML Robert Fox HIGH. |
| [14:39] | Clear attempt by VWCM good. |
| [13:39] | Shot by VWCM Josh Currier WIDE. |
| [13:30] | Turnover by VWCM Tim Gunn. |
| [13:25] | Ground ball pickup by RMCML Louie Bafford. |
| [13:23] | Clear attempt by RMCML good. |
| [12:45] | Shot by RMCML Robert Fox WIDE. |
| [12:39] | Shot by RMCML Jason Andrews WIDE. |
| [12:24] | Shot by RMCML Justin Butler, SAVE Corey Bauer. |
| [11:58] | Turnover by RMCML Jason Andrews. |
| [11:49] | Ground ball pickup by VWCM Corey Bauer. |
| [11:40] | Clear attempt by VWCM good. |
| [11:17] | Shot by VWCM Joe Papetti WIDE. |
| [10:51] | Ground ball pickup by VWCM Mikey Connors. |
| [10:51] | GOAL by VWCM Mikey Connors. |
| Virginia Wesleyan 15, Randolph-Macon 12 |
| [10:51] | Faceoff Nick Benhoff vs James Alvarez won by RMCML, [10:51] Ground ball pickup by RMCML Nick Benhoff. |
| [10:26] | Shot by RMCML Robert Fox WIDE. |
| [10:09] | Shot by RMCML Josh Merwin WIDE. |
| [09:57] | GOAL by RMCML Josh Merwin. |
| Virginia Wesleyan 15, Randolph-Macon 13 |
| [09:57] | Faceoff Nick Benhoff vs Sam Limpert won by VWCM, [09:57] Ground ball pickup by VWCM Mikey Connors. |
| [09:47] | Clear attempt by VWCM good. |
| [09:15] | Ground ball pickup by VWCM Mikey Connors. |
| [09:13] | Shot by VWCM Mikey Connors, SAVE Thomas Smith. |
| [09:09] | Clear attempt by RMCML good. |
| [08:33] | Shot by RMCML Nick Benhoff WIDE. |
| [08:33] | Penalty on VWCM Nick Pappas (SLASHING/0:30) Extra-man opportunity. |
| [08:19] | GOAL by RMCML Josh Merwin, Assist by Justin Butler. |
| Virginia Wesleyan 15, Randolph-Macon 14 |
| [08:19] | Faceoff Nick Benhoff vs Sam Limpert won by RMCML, [08:19] Ground ball pickup by RMCML Nick Benhoff. |
| [07:33] | Shot by RMCML Josh Merwin HIT POST. |
| [07:09] | Ground ball pickup by RMCML Justin Butler. |
| [06:57] | Shot by RMCML Tim Rowe HIGH. |
| [06:47] | Shot by RMCML Ryan Davidson, SAVE Corey Bauer. |
| [06:40] | Clear attempt by VWCM good. |
| [06:19] | Shot by VWCM Josh Currier WIDE. |
| [05:59] | Ground ball pickup by VWCM Tim Gunn. |
| [05:38] | Shot by VWCM Josh Currier, SAVE Thomas Smith. |
| [05:00] | Shot by VWCM Mikey Connors WIDE. |
| [04:52] | Shot by VWCM Nick Pappas, SAVE Thomas Smith. |
| [04:48] | Ground ball pickup by RMCML Bobby Bailey. |
| [04:45] | Clear attempt by RMCML failed. |
| [02:11] | Turnover by RMCML Bobby Bailey. |
| [04:37] | Ground ball pickup by VWCM Nick Pappas. |
| [04:37] | GOAL by VWCM Nick Pappas. |
| Virginia Wesleyan 16, Randolph-Macon 14 |
| [04:37] | Faceoff Nick Benhoff vs Sam Limpert won by RMCML, [04:37] Ground ball pickup by RMCML Nick Benhoff. |
| [03:54] | GOAL by RMCML Justin Butler. |
| Virginia Wesleyan 16, Randolph-Macon 15 |
| [03:54] | Faceoff Nick Benhoff vs Mikey Connors won by VWCM, [03:54] Ground ball pickup by VWCM Mikey Connors. |
| [03:42] | Turnover by VWCM Mikey Connors. |
| [03:37] | Ground ball pickup by RMCML Nick Benhoff. |
| [03:35] | Clear attempt by RMCML good. |
| [03:06] | GOAL by RMCML Robert Fox. |
| Randolph-Macon 16, Virginia Wesleyan 16 |
| [03:06] | Faceoff Nick Benhoff vs Mikey Connors won by VWCM, [03:06] Ground ball pickup by VWCM Mikey Connors. |
| [02:55] | Shot by VWCM Mikey Connors HIGH. |
| [02:33] | Shot by VWCM Joe Papetti WIDE. |
| [02:28] | Ground ball pickup by VWCM Nick Pappas. |
| [02:22] | Shot by VWCM Mike Moran HIGH. |
| [02:17] | Ground ball pickup by VWCM Josh Currier. |
| [02:14] | Shot by VWCM Nick Pappas WIDE. |
| [01:48] | Turnover by VWCM Tim Gunn. |
| [01:47] | Clear attempt by RMCML good. |
| [00:45] | GOAL by RMCML Jason Andrews. |
| Randolph-Macon 17, Virginia Wesleyan 16 |
| [00:45] | Faceoff Nick Benhoff vs Mikey Connors won by RMCML, [00:45] Ground ball pickup by RMCML Nick Benhoff. |
| [00:37] | Turnover by RMCML Nick Benhoff. |
| [00:33] | Ground ball pickup by VWCM Joe Papetti. |
| [00:26] | Ground ball pickup by VWCM Josh Currier. |
| [00:12] | Penalty on RMCML Henson Ford (HOLDING/0:30) Extra-man opportunity. |
| [00:02] | Shot by VWCM Mike Moran HIGH. |
| [00:00] | End-of-period. |